Why were ancient people interested in astronomylink to a key question

Key points: How the phases of the moon, the seasons, and eclipses work

Ancient man had much darker skies and was much more familiar with events in nature than we are. Here is a picture of the dark sky from Mt. Graham, pretty much what would have been seen any clear night anywhere in ancient timeslink to an extra topic.(from http://medusa.as.arizona.edu/graham/graham.html)

View of the sky from Mount Graham, Arizona

A big challenge was to understand the systematic and repeating changes that occur in the sky.

Every day:

But note that

Every month:

animation of lunar phases

(Thanks to Antonio Cidadao http://www.astrosurf.com/cidadao/animations.htm)

Late, late yestreen I saw the new moone,
Wi’ the auld moon in hir arme.

- Thomas Percy, Sir Patrick Spensmoonarms.jpg (9649 bytes)

Sometimes we can see a bright, thin crescent with a faintly lit full disk - poetically termed the new moon with the old moon in its arms!

new moon quarter moon full moon

new

quarter

full

More or less, the moon's phases go through the same pattern every 29-30 days.

Every year:

The collection of constellations that the sun moves across during the course of the year is called the zodiac. The sun’s path across the stars is call the ecliptic.

On top of these complexities, from time to time there is an eclipse of the moon, a shower of meteors, appearance of a comet, or very rarely the sun is eclipsed.

How do the motions of planets, the moon, and the earth affect everyday liveslink to a key question

How can we explain all of these observations?

The challenge of explaining the precise and repeating events in the sky played a key role in developing scientific thinking in general buttonex.jpg (1228 bytes)
Had we never seen the stars, and the sun, and the heaven, none of the words which we have spoken about the universe would ever have been uttered. But now the sight of day and night, and the months and the revolutions of the years, have created a number, and have given us a conception of time, and the power of enquiring about the nature of the universe; and from this source we have derived philosophy, than which no greater good ever was or will be given by the gods to mortal man.

-- the great Greek philosopher Plato (427 - 347 B. C., in Timaeus), describing the origins of ancient Greek science

We now know that

1) Rotation of the earth causes the daily motion of the sun and stars.

2) Motion of the earth around the sun causes the sun to appear to move and changes which stars are visible at night.

3) Seasons arise from the combination of the earth moving around the sun and the 23.5 degree tilt of the axis of the earth relative to its orbit.

The third point needs a bit more explanation:

seasonorb.gif (78233 bytes) Here, we watch the earth go around the sun (highly not to scale!). Its axis always points the same way, somewhere way up to the right. Thus, when it is to the left of the sun in this animation, it points the northern hemisphere toward the sun and it is summer there. The south is pointed away, and it is winter there. When it is to the right of the sun, it points the southern hemisphere toward the sun and it is summer there (and winter in the north). The "solstices" are when the hemispheres are pointed as close or as far away from the sun as possible, and the "equinoxes" are exactly in between.Thus, the "summer solstice," on or about June 22, is when the sun passes closest to directly overhead in northern areas, and the "winter solstice", on or about December 22, when its highest point on the sky (that is, at noon) is as low as possible. The equinoxes are on or about March 22 and September 22. (animation by G. Rieke, Earth views from The Living Earth, http://www.fourmilab.ch/)
animation showing why seasons occur depending on how high sun is overhead

 

The change in seasons results from the change in the power received at the ground depending on how high the sun goes overhead. This animation (by G. Rieke) shows the change in power received on an area of fixed size in the summer and the winter. In the winter, the area is tilted away relative to the beam of sunlight, causing less total light to strike it (think about the arctic circle, which is the spot where the surface of the earth is tilted to be edge-on to the sun at the deepest point of winter - any energy reaching the ground at the arctic circle (and within it) must be carried there by winds in the atmosphere from regions heated directly). (animation by G. Rieke)

Another way to think of seasons is to imagine you are at the sun, looking at the earth. Regions you can't see can't receive any sunlight, while regions that are tilted toward you so they are easy to see will receive a lot.

The progression for northern Europe is shown below, with the earth as viewed from the sun to the right and an illustrative painting from Pieter Brueghel's cycle of the months to the left (for Spring, we had to substitute "The Fall of Icarus," since the cycle painting is lost). See how much the view of Europe, as seen from the sun, changes as the earth goes around on its orbit! When it is winter, northern Europe is way up where light from the sun can hardly get to it, whereas in the summer it has a straight shotbuttonbook.jpg (10323 bytes). (animation by G. Rieke, Earth views from The Living Earth, http://www.fourmilab.ch/)
seasonsanim.gif (900309 bytes)

 

Behavior of the Moon

Phases

The changing appearance of the moon over a monthly cycle is due to the Moon’s orbital motion around the Earth coupled with the relatively great distance of the Sunlink to an extra topic

Here is how it works. The side of the moon that is toward the sun is the one that is lit up (naturally!). As the moon orbits, we see more or less of this side, depending on where it is on the orbit. (By G. Rieke. Thanks also to Antonio Cidadao)

See http://astro.unl.edu/naap/lps/animations/moonBisectorDemo.html for a demo of how this works (to get started, click on boxes 1 and 3 and then try the sun direction and moon position sliders).

animation of phases of moon

With the help of the animation, see if you can answer these questions:

Eclipses

Eclipses caused great awe and fear in ancient times, as shown by the quotation to the right. In fact they are just the consequence of the earth, sun, and moon all lining up together and the earth and moon casting shadows on each other.

"Nothing is strange, nothing impossible

Nor marvellous, since Zeus the father of gods

Brought night to midday when he hid the light

Of the shining sun. Grim fear has smitten us,

And anything can happen to mankind.

Let no man marvel if he sees the flocks

Yield up their grassy pasture to the dolphins

And seek the salty billows of the deep,

Grown dearer to them than their native meadows,

While to the fishes sweeter seem the mountains.":

-- Archilochus, on the solar eclipse of April 6, 648 B. C.

eclipses depend on where moon is on its orbit If the moon is between the earth and the sun, we have a solar eclipse which is visible along a narrow region of the earth’s surface where the moon’s shadow hits the earth.

 

 

 

 

The appearance of the eclipse depends on the exact position of the moon on its orbit, involving both whether the moon blocks the sun exactly ("totality") and also how far it is from the earth.

(From The Essential Cosmic Perspective, Bennett et al.)

animation of eclipse shadow on Earth

To the left is how the shadow passes over the earth.

(From F. Espenak via Mreclipse.com, http://www.mreclipse.com/TSE99reports/image/T99video1.gif)

Below is a movie of the real thing observed from a satellite:

ecliseanim.gif (1936544 bytes)

from the European Organization for the Exploitation of Meteorological Satellites, http://www.eumetsat.de/

 

animation showing solar eclipse and here is how the eclipse looks as viewed from an optimum spot, in the path of "totality".

(From F. Espenak,  http://sunearth.gsfc.nasa.gov/eclipse/TSE2001/T01animate.html)

Because the moon has to be between the earth and the sun, a solar eclipse can only occur at new moon. It can only be seen at the specific spot where the moon casts a shadow on the earth. To the right, a series of images captures a solar eclipse over Monument Valley (from APOD, Tunc Teze. (TWAN))

Lunar eclipse over Arizona

If the earth is between the sun and the moon (full moon), a lunar eclipse can occur, where the full moon is darkened by the earth’s shadow. Everyone on the nighttime side of Earth can see a lunar eclipse.

animation showing lunar eclipse

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

(Thanks to Antonio Cidadao http://www.astrosurf.com/cidadao/animations.htm) and Wikipedia

Why aren’t there eclipses every month?

Because the moon’s orbit is tilted by 5 degrees with respect to the plane defined by the earth and the sun, the shadows of Moon or Earth may miss the other body.  (Illustration by G. Rieke, after N. Strobel)

effect of tilt of Moon's orbit on occurence of eclipses

Only when the moon is simultaneously either new or full and passing through the plane of the earth’s orbit around the Sun do eclipses occur. (From Chaisson & McMillan, Astronomy Today)

The tilt of the moon;s orbit compared with that of the earth results in eclipses only at certain times

Test your understanding before going onbuttongrad.jpg (11232 bytes)

sun_temple_inca.jpg (22658 bytes)

 

 

 

 

Entrance to the Sun Temple, Machu Picchu, from Windows to the Universe, http://www.windows.ucar.edu/

sirtflaunch.jpg (4413 bytes)

nocturnal.jpg (10911 bytes)

 

 

Observing with a "nocturnal," from http://www.math.nus.edu.sg/aslaksen/teaching/heavenly.shtml

Click to return to syllabus

Click to go to Scales in the Universe

hypertext copyright.jpg (1684 bytes) G. H. Rieke

Click for Beginnings of Astronomy