|Galileo lived at about the same time as Kepler (they did their most important work
around 1600-1610) and exchanged letters with him.
He made a number of fundamental contributions to our understanding of the solar system and the laws of physics. See http://es.rice.edu/ES/humsoc/Galileo/.
Key points: Importance of doing experiments; birth of modern physics and how it differed from medieval physics; discoveries of moons of Jupiter, phases of Venus and impact on solar system theories
|He introduced the idea of making measurements or experiments to understand how things happen.||Pure logical thinking cannot yield us any knowledge of the
empirical world; all knowledge of reality starts from experience and ends in it...Galileo
saw this, and particularly because he drummed it into the scientific world, he is the
father of modern physics - indeed, of modern science altogether.
-- Albert Einstein
|Galileo's greatest contribution to physics (after the notion of doing experiments at all) was his studies of the motions of objects. He rolled balls down an inclined plane to "slow down" their falling and study it. In this re-creation, the plane is equipped with bells arranged so they would ring as the balls passed. By adjusting the positions of the bells, he could compare with time standards (perhaps his singing!). (It is not known that Galileo did this exact experiment.)(Pictures from Museum of Science, Florence).|
He also recognized the value of the pendulum for accurate time keeping Pendulum clocks set the standard for accuracy for centuries.
|Pendulum clock (far left) constructed from a drawing by
Galileo (left) (model from Museum of Science, Florence)
(From Museum of Science and Technology, http://www.sciencemuseum.org.uk/collections/exhiblets/huygens/galileo.asp
He developed the concept of inertia: if an object is at rest, it will stay at rest unless something acts upon it to move it. Similarly, if an object is moving in a straight line at constant speed, it will continue to do so unless something acts upon it.
This realization had escaped people because friction is so prevalent and it provides a force that usually causes moving objects to slow down.
He used the newly invented telescope to observe a number of astronomical phenomena (Pictures from Museum of Science, Florence)
These observations (stars in the Milky Way, geologic structures on the Moon, sunspots) dont provide any test for or against the Copernican model of the solar system. However, sunspots, for example, do provide evidence that the heavens are not perfect and unchanging as described by Aristotle, Ptolemy, and other ancients.
(From R. Baalke, http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/galileo/ganymede/discovery.html)
The moons that Galileo observed orbiting Jupiter again did not prove the Copernican concept, but they appeared to support it indirectly. They proved that not everything orbits the Earth. Furthermore, Jupiter and its moons actually look like a miniature solar system in many respects. The fact that Jupiter can move through space and not leave its moons behind supports the concept that the Earth can move without leaving its moon behind.
|The phases of Venus were a convincing demonstration of the heliocentric solar system, or at least that Venus comes between the earth and sun as it predicted (and contrary to the Ptolemaic system). They result from its position in the solar system between us and the sun. Mercury also exhibits phases but its much harder to observe than Venus. The Ptolemaic system could explain only some of the phases exhibited by Venus.|
|In the Ptolemaic system (left), Venus always lies between the sun and the earth and it would always show a crescent phase. The Copernican system (right) predicts a full range of phases for Venus as it passes from between the sun and the earth to being on the opposite side of the sun from the earth. (from Parvis Ansari http://artsci.shu.edu/physics/1007/historylv.html)|
|From Scott Anderson, copyright open course, http://www.opencourse.info/||Watch in the animation as Venus (the purple dot in the right panel) comes around the sun and goes between it and the earth.|
Galileos law of inertia provided some hints about how the planets must move:
1) if there is no friction in space, then planets would be able to move forever without changing their paths or losing their energy of motion
2) since planets move in curved paths rather than straight lines, there must be some force acting on them to change direction
But Galileo was not able to put the above facts together with Keplers Laws to come up with the final explanation of why the planets move as they do.
However, the combination of Keplers Laws and Galileos observations provided the death knell for the Ptolemaic System. Galileo realized this, but his over-zealous promotion led to the famous conflict with the Catholic Church. As discussed in this link in more detail, many of the problems arose because both Galileo and the Church mixed science and politics (in this case, religious politics). Doing so seems always to lead to trouble. In fact, at the beginning, both parties agreed that the Copernican system was useful as an idea and that it could be explored as a scientific hypothesis. As time went on and Galileo became more adamant about promoting it as true fact (which he could not establish), the conservative members of the clergy who were concerned about the implications for Church teachings and the status of them reacted by trying to restrict Galileo's statements. He counter-reacted by making them more and more vehemently. If Galileo had stuck to his science, and the Church had let him, then history might be different.
Kepler's system to left, has the sun at the center and all the planets orbiting it, from http://www.umich.edu/~iinet/crees/regionalstudies/polish/wodiczko_lecture.htm)
Newton, by William Blake, http://www.princeton.edu/~his291/Newton.html
Click to return to syllabus
|Click to return to Kepler||
hypertext G. H. Rieke
Click to advance to Newton